This article appears in the January 2019 issue of Potato Grower.
What does archaeology tell us about the antiquity of potatoes as food? In southern Chile, near the limits of potato-forming Solanum species along the Andean Cordillera, small pieces of tuber have been excavated from a 15,000-year-old hearth at a site called Monte Verde. Although it’s still unclear as to the identity of those fragments, this use of a wild potato species is at least 7,000 years older than the domestication of Solanum tuberosum, the modern cultivated potato species.
In the opposite hemisphere, at the northern limit of all potato-forming Solanum species, starch grains of the native Solanum jamesii were identified on the surface of a 10,900-year-old grinding stone from a rock shelter in southern Utah. Soon after that, a live population comprised of 22 robust plants was found within 100 meters of that ancient habitation. Subsequent field work has identified at least eight remnant populations of this “Four Corners Potato” in the Escalante region and four within Bears Ears National Monument in southeastern Utah. At least nine of these 12 are associated with archaeological features, including habitations, storage granaries, pottery sherds, stone tools and petroglyphs.
Is it possible that S. jamesii had been domesticated, given its long history and strong association with human activity? Our project is designed to answer that question through a collaboration between a botanic garden, a natural history museum, the tribes of the Four Corners region (Utah, Colorado, New Mexico and Arizona), and a government potato genebank. If native people had transported, cultivated and selected tubers away from the center of distribution (in south-central Arizona, New Mexico and Texas), we would expect to find genetic, ecological and reproductive traits that reflect past manipulation. In that case, this would be the only known plant species to be domesticated in the western United States. Comparisons could then be made with the domestication of S. tuberosum as it is understood in South America, as well as with other important crops (e.g., corn, beans, squash and peppers) from Mesoamerica.
The USDA’s Potato Genebank in Wisconsin holds a vast collection of tubers from many species in the Western Hemisphere as part of an effort to understand how potato diversity was created and how that diversity can be perpetuated. Over 100 populations of S. jamesii are represented, containing genes that confer greater blight and nematode resistance, as well as tolerance to freezing. Hybrids of S. jamesii and other species have potential to improve S. tuberosum and to develop new useful strains. In some ways, this research mimics the mixing and selection conducted by Andean people that resulted in the more than 4,500 cultivars of S. tuberosum. We even suspect that the ancient Puebloan city in southwester, Colorado known now as Mesa Verde, may have served as the S. jamesii genebank of its time, owing to high levels of genetic diversity that appear to have been transported and cultivated there long ago.
In addition to exploring the question of ancient domestication, we are also engaged with tribes in the Four Corners region who have a long cultural relationship with S. jamesii and detailed knowledge of its biology. Elders still eat these small tubers, gathered from carefully tended populations. Some grow the species in gardens and regard it as a sacred food, lifeway medicine and gift of the holy people. Consequently, the Four Corners potato reconnects tribes to intact landscapes and traditional agricultural practices, helping revitalize indigenous food heritage. Understanding the ancient potato heritage from the native perspective includes the spiritual and traditional aspects of bringing old teachings back to life with the intention of healing and nurturing, protecting whole and natural systems of the land, and strengthening tribal cultures and knowledge systems for future generations.
We also see great potential for practical benefit of the Four Corners Potato to tribes who can grow and market it, landowners who conserve it on their properties, and restaurants that offer it as part of a burgeoning food movement. Plants in cultivation grow rapidly during summer months, and one individual is able to produce hundreds of new—albeit small—tubers by late fall. They store well when refrigerated, maintain integrity when cooked for prolonged periods, and have twice the protein, zinc and manganese and three times the calcium and iron content of most white potato cultivars.
They are also delicious, but some populations contain more of the bitter glycoalkaloids known from all Solanum species. These can be removed using traditional cooking techniques, but we are also searching for the best-tasting strains to use as source material for commercialization. Those strains often occur on private land, so landowners will be contacted and included in development of this product, especially if they implement simple measures that protect populations as well as the archaeology. Finally, we have the enthusiastic support of restaurants in the region who recognize the ancient culinary history and are excited to add this 10,900-year-old food to their menus.
Bruce Pavlik is the director of conservation at the University of Utah’s Red Butte Garden in Salt Lake City. Cynthia Wilson serves as traditional foods program director with Utah Diné Bikéyah in Salt Lake City. John Bamberg is a geneticist and project leader, and Alfonso del Rio is an associate scientist, both with the USDA-ARS’s U.S. Potato Genebank in Sturgeon Bay, Wis. Lisbeth Louderback is the curator of archaeology for the Natural History Museum of Utah and a professor for the University of Utah.